On Comments

Due to the nature of what has been happening with The Green Carnation Longlist post and its comments we have been asked by one of the authors discussed to take down the anonymous negative comments regarding them. We have also spoken with the judges and decided if we are to do that then we should also take the negative comments regarding the prize and its judges off the site… so there are now a lot less comments all in all!

We had really hoped for an enlivened debate on the longlist and discussion that we could all get involved in. However these comments have become derogatory to the judges (who have invested hours of their free time), some authors and indeed the prize itself and so now all comments will need to be approved before being shown on the site full stop.

Moderating the site and its up keep takes time and no one is being paid to keep this running. So if comments keep on arriving of the same nature this will simply have to become a ‘comment free’ site – which would be a shame as we do want to discuss the long list with you and the prize as it goes forward.

It’s rather sad that a prize which has been started in order to celebrate gay authors and gay writing has already been made slightly murky by some negative and hurtful comments to several parties. This was meant to be done in the spirit of community and sadly it seems some people in that community want to see it collapse because people they love didn’t get long listed. Shouldn’t we be celebrating was HAS been put through and mentioning what we would have liked to have seen on the list in a civil calm way without negativity?

It’s been a weird week since the long list was announced, so we are now drawing a line under it.

In other news we are very excited as it looks like The Green Carnation Prize 2011 is going to be even bigger and better than this year, more on that in the months to come.

Many thanks

The Green Carnation Team

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to On Comments

  1. amymckie says:

    It’s sad to see the negativity, I think deleting the comments was the best idea. I hope that, moving forward, things can stay more positive.

  2. I applaud your efforts and work. Sadly I see this sort of thing happening a lot: people who freely give their time for an artistic cause that they love being beaten down because some people don’t agree with choices that are made. So I hope you aren’t discouraged and continue on.
    I look forward to seeing the shortlist.

  3. Oh dear, I made a comment about being disappointed with one of the longlist choices. I hope I did so respectfully and am not one of the people you are referring to. If I am, please forgive me. I think you all have done a fantastic job.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s